The True Story of Robert the Doll and Eugene Otto

The True Story of Robert the Doll and Eugene Otto

Photo of author
Written By Haunting Realm

Adventurer. Cryptozoology enthusiast. Paranormal investigator. Storyteller.

In this article...

In the early 1900s, a servant gifted a handmade doll to a young boy named Eugene Robert Otto. The boy named the doll Robert and grew attached to it. However, despite its seemingly ordinary appearance, strange and disturbing occurrences began to happen with the doll.

The world is filled with tales of haunted objects and ghostly encounters, but few stories are as chilling and enigmatic as that of Robert the Doll. 

Born out of the imagination of Robert Eugene Otto, this eerie toy has captured the fascination of believers and skeptics alike. 

Who was Robert Eugene Otto?

Robert Eugene Otto was a prominent artist and eccentric personality who lived in Key West, Florida, during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. 

Robert Eugene Otto, commonly known and referred to as Gene, was born in sunny Florida, USA, on October 25, 1900, to wealthy and well-traveled parents Thomas Osgood Otto Sr. (35) and Minnie Elizabeth Watkins (32). 

From a young age, Robert displayed a deep interest in the arts, and he pursued this passion by studying in New York and Paris. His exceptional talent and hard work soon led him to become a highly respected artist and author in his Key West, Florida hometown. 

Despite Robert’s impressive achievements, his parents were notoriously strict disciplinarians known to mistreat their household staff. 

Interesting read: Where to Find Ghosts: Top 10 Best Places to Go Ghost Hunting for Those Brave Enough

This unfortunate behavior cast a shadow over the otherwise idyllic family life that Robert experienced growing up. Nevertheless, Robert persevered and continued to pursue his creative passions, leaving a lasting legacy that has inspired countless individuals to this day.

However, it was during his early childhood that he received a peculiar gift that would change his life forever.

The True Story of Robert the Doll

The true story of Robert the Doll began in 1904 when a mysterious Jamaican servant presented Robert Eugene Otto with a handmade doll. 

Crafted with remarkable detail and wearing a sailor suit – based on Robert Eugene Otto’s outfit during childhood – the toy became an instant companion for the young boy. He affectionately named it Robert, after himself, and the two quickly became inseparable. 

In another version of the story, the toy was a gift from Mr. Thomas Otto for his beloved son. In this interpretation of the story, the doll Thomas Otto purchased the doll from a toy store on his way back home.

Robert the doll real story
According to the Steiff Company, Robert may have been initially created as one of several dolls designed for a clown or jester-themed window display. Photo credit: Key West Art & Historical Society.

The German company Steiff created the toy around the turn of the century. Steiff is a plush toy company founded in 1880 by Margarete Steiff, known for producing top-quality stuffed animals, including the first teddy bear, in 1902.

Regardless of the toy’s true origin, little did Robert know this innocent-looking doll would soon be at the center of a haunting mystery.

The Haunting Lore of Robert the Doll

The true story of Robert the Doll continues with a series of unexplained paranormal phenomena.

A Startling Encounter

One particular night, Gene awoke to find Robert positioned at the foot of his bed, prompting him to scream for assistance. Gene’s mother responded to his cries and discovered him in a state of distress while Robert remained seated at the bed’s edge. 

You may also like: Resurrection Mary: The Eerie Tale of Chicago’s Most Famous Ghost

This occurrence was the initial indication that something inexplicable was transpiring.

Throughout his formative years, Gene had a tendency to blame his mischievous tendencies on his beloved toy, Robert. There was something peculiar about the toy that made it seem as though it had a life of its own. 

The Growing Strange Occurrences

As Robert Eugene Otto grew older, strange occurrences began surrounding the doll. 

Witnesses reported seeing Robert move independently, his eerie laughter echoing through the hallways. Some claimed to have witnessed the doll’s expression change as if it were alive. 

Even more unsettling, there were whispers that the doll could speak. Visitors to the Otto household would often hear a faint voice responding to Robert’s conversations with the doll.

A Lifelong Bond

Despite growing more mature, Gene never parted ways with Robert and eventually moved into his childhood home with his spouse. In fact, he designated a room with a clear view of the street specifically for the doll. 

It was clear that Robert held a special place in Gene’s heart and life, despite the oddities surrounding the toy.

On May 3, 1930, Robert Eugene Otto and Annette “Anne” Parker were joined in matrimony in the beautiful city of Paris, Seine, France. Following their nuptials, the couple settled in the charming town of Coral Gables, Dade, Florida.

But the marriage didn’t break the unnatural link between Eugene and his toy, as they remained inseparable for many years.

After Gene’s parents died, he returned to their home with his wife, Anne. Gene decided that the doll needed his own room and placed him in the upstairs room with a window overlooking the street.

Unsettling Manifestations

Anne had a peculiar intuition about Robert and decided to confide in Gene to safeguard their home. She requested Gene to secure Robert in the attic, as she felt uneasy around him. 

However, Robert was not pleased with this decision and strange occurrences began manifesting in the house. Visitors reported hearing footsteps and eerie laughter that could only be described as demonic. 

The children in the household even claimed to see Robert staring at them from the upstairs window, taunting them with his presence. 

Even Gene was astonished to discover Robert sitting in the upstairs bedroom, despite being previously locked up in the attic. This bizarre incident continued to happen multiple times, leaving everyone in the house puzzled and frightened.

In 1972, a guest reported feeling an inexplicable sense of dread while observing the doll. Shortly after the encounter, the person fell gravely ill, prompting speculation about the doll’s malevolent influence.

Young Robert Gene Otto
On the right side of the picture is the young Robert Eugene Otto, dressed in a sailor’s suit that would later inspire the famous Robert’s outfit. Image credit: Otto Family Collection/Florida Keys Public Library/Flickr.

The Curse and Unanswered Questions

Gene died at 73 on June 24, 1974, in Key West, Monroe, Florida, and was laid to rest in Key West Cemetery. Following the passing of Gene Otto, a new household took up residence in his former abode along Eaton Street. 

But as you probably expect, the true story of Robert the Doll doesn’t end here. (You can also read more about this haunted doll and the mysterious curse surrounding it in this article here.)

The family’s ten-year-old daughter chanced upon Robert the Doll while exploring the attic and was initially overjoyed at the discovery. However, her joy was short-lived as she soon claimed the doll was sentient and harbored malicious intent towards her. 

The child’s distress escalated to the point where she woke up frequently in the middle of the night screaming in terror and alleging that Robert was moving about her room. 

Subsequently, the doll was relinquished and currently resides in the East Martello Fort, where it is a popular attraction for visitors from all over the globe.

A prevalent belief among many is that the servant who presented Robert to Gene Otto placed a curse of Voodoo and Black Magic on the doll as a means of retribution for perceived mistreatment by Gene’s parents. 

This theory could potentially provide an explanation for the numerous alarming experiences that people have had with Robert. However, the reasons for the haunting persisting even after the owners’ passing remain unclear. 

Regardless, Robert the Doll instills fear and unease in those who come to see it at the museum, particularly those attempting to capture photographs. 

Where is the Doll Now?

Robert the Doll is currently housed at the Fort East Martello Museum in Key West, Florida. The museum, located within a historic fort built in 1862, is dedicated to preserving local history and culture.

The Fort East Martello Museum is a unique attraction, showcasing diverse exhibits, including military artifacts, artwork, and local memorabilia. Visitors can explore the fort’s architecture, learn about Key West’s maritime history, and delve into the intriguing world of paranormal phenomena.

However, many visitors have reported camera malfunctioning when photographing Robert, only for the devices to resume functioning upon leaving the museum. 

Despite being kept within a glass enclosure, Robert’s presence still unsettles museum personnel and visitors alike.

A group of paranormal investigators conducted an overnight vigil at the museum in 2003. During their stay, they captured chilling EVP (Electronic Voice Phenomenon) recordings, catching faint whispers and unexplained noises believed to originate from the doll.

The Legacy of Robert the Doll

Robert Eugene Otto passed away in 1974, leaving a legacy that still captivates people today. The tales of Robert the Doll continue to thrive, with many attributing unexplained occurrences and bizarre events to the doll’s curse. 

The true story of Robert the Doll continues and the haunting legend has inspired movies, books, and numerous urban legends that permeate popular culture.


  • Robert (doll). Wikipedia. [Source]
  • Ella Morton – Robert the Haunted Doll: Creeping Out Floridians Since 1904.
  • Robert the Haunted Doll.
  • Rosalie Ann – Robert Eugene “Gene” Otto. [Source]
  • Steiff company official website. [Source]
  • Featured image credit: Cayobo. [Source]